1.16.2011

The Winter of my Discontent

We don't talk about it.

Not in polite company, anyhow. 

And needless to say, we love our children, we love our spouses. We love many things. 

But then there are those things. The things that haunt the dreams, the things that culminate in middle-aged depression. Those things that creep into the shadows of our discontent, and become poisonous leeches in our soul; threatening to capsize our way of life.

The things that, when we were 19 or 25, we were certain we would do, someday. The things that are our purpose, our mission, our calling. Those things that our life couldn't possibly result in NOT being, because those things are who we are, integrally, intrinsically.

But we are told along the way, or maybe we learn by osmosis through the languishing of older people we know, who wag their wise fingers and say, "Be content. Love the life you live", that those things are childish fantasy, and we must soon learn to live in the real world -- the mature world.

But somehow, you cannot. You don't love the life. You hate to bake, you do not sew; hell you don't even own a machine. You don't like domesticity, not one iota. Or you hate your job, but cannot escape it because it pays the bills or because you aren't trained for anything else.  And yet, it seems to think it is what you signed up for. And you regret it. Or maybe you just signed up for it a mite too soon, before the dreams had a chance to take flight and tire you out. Or flesh themselves out into some alternate version of reality.

And at 40, we begin to realize that someday will never come. We will never be who we thought we would be when we were 19, or 25.

We have mortgages and grocery bills and marriages and commitments. We may have chosen them, or they have chosen us, or we may have wandered blindly into them, once upon a time when we believed we knew what we wanted but really knew nothing at all.  

Sometimes those things awaken us in the night. Those things. Those things, that in the reality of our best optimism will never come to pass. Those things that we define ourselves by, even if they have never materialized.

And yet, somewhere along the way, we learn that, quite possibly, those unrealized dreams are nothing more than fantasy. We might see the fork in the road in perfect hindsight. We may know exactly what we would have done differently. But we also know that life isn't a 'Choose Your Own Adventure' book; least of not having any chance to go back and try again. We cannot ever know what direction those forks in the road may have actually taken us. Possibly somewhere greater than we imagined. Just as likely, not. 

What is sensibility? When are we to be old enough to give up on the old dreams? When might we learn that quite possibly there ought to be new, more manageable, more achievable dreams ought to replace them?

Because I haven't learned it yet, apparently. As much as my intellect screams at me for being a spoiled brat, I cannot find smaller dreams that have the potential to fulfill me. And yet, that same intellect tells me I'm doomed for disappointment and ought to stand down and be content.

Well. I'm decidedly not content. Polite company or not, I have dreams on this mountain of mine. Dreams that are MINE. Dreams that are not driven by the demands of others. Dreams that I still shake my fist at, dreams that still see me stand and holler that I WILL catch up to them some day, before I die. 
"I have dreamed on this mountain,
since first I was my mother's daughter,
and you can't just take my dreams away,
not with me watching.
You may drive a big machine,
but I was born a great big woman,
and you can't just take my dreams away,
not with me fighting.
This old mountain raised my many daughters,
some died young – some are still living,
but if you come here to take our mountain,
well we ain't come here to give it.
I have dreamed on this mountain,
since first I was my mother's daughter,
and you can't just take my dreams away,
not with me watching.
No you can't just take my dreams away,
without me fighting.
No you can't just take my dreams away."
-- 'Mountain Song' by Holly Near,
-- as performed by Star Nayea & Primeaux & Mike
-- from 'Sacred Ground: a Tribute to Mother Earth'
I am still seeking that which will fulfill me. That thing that is attainable, that will cause my unrealized dreams to fade into the past as a new and realized dream takes its place. For that is the true stepping stone, a bridge between the past and the present. The thing, this, the one thing that will fill the gaping void of what never came to pass with contentment and peace. Maybe we didn't know as much when we were 19 or 25 as we like to think we knew.

I don't think we can really begin to know our purpose until the middle of life comes and goes. Only then will we, perhaps in light of the wisdom of what we have dreamed but know will never be, understand what is meant to be. And those new dreams move mountains.

Some call it a mid-life crisis. I call it a great awakening.

22 comments:

  1. Great post, Erin. When it comes down to it, your purpose is to be you. I know that sounds trite, but it's true. Go with that 'awakening', and remember the butterfly's wing that causes the hurricane. Everything we think, say, do is significant. But only everything:)

    Now, Monday, have at you!:)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Erin,I identify with all of this! xx
    Annie

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can't believe how deep it all goes as we get older. I never had any idea about that, when I was young and living out on the top of things.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Erin,
    Your post reminds me of a great piece of wisdom from Anne Morrow Lindbergh -- It's from The Gift of the Sea, which is worth reading in any case. She has a lovely meditation on middle age and compares its restlessness and discontent to adolescence. We tend to encourage that restlessness in youth as part of growing, but get scared by it in midlife because we interpret it as signs of approaching death. She has a great line about standing in "that breathtaking empty space of an open door." Here's to taking that first step!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dreams. Purpose. Big topics!

    Approaching 50, I am amazed the the events of my life have not completely squashed the dreams right out of me. But they linger, persist, are irritants in the complacent places of life. And like all good irritants, they appear to have formed unexpected pearls here and there. But they are also unfulfilled and I am not as content as I would like to be, either. I am currently in that delicate balance of not letting go of all my childhood dreams while at the same time just following the path where it leads and trusting that purpose will arise on the path as I go.... when I was in the turning 40 place, I felt that "just let go of your great aspirations and be content where you are..." It has faded and the hope for dreams to come true has been renewed.

    Hmm...sometimes, I'm not sure 'content' is even a place we should linger long.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I can relate, and I'm not quite 40 yet!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sorry for the tardy replies - I took the kids to the coast for a 3 day weekend, and just didn't have time until now.

    Harry - I get that, and I try to take it to heart. But I do still have dreams. Being just me as I am right now is unfulfilling...I know there's more to me.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ann - Glad I'm not the only one!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Maria - That sounds like an interesting book. I hate that we're not "allowed" to be restless and reckless when we are middle aged. Too much propriety says we must work and raise our families and be content, and repeat until we die. I don't want to be that person, but neither do I want to abandon my responsibilities. Trying to find a middle ground.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Katherine - Agreed. I'm not ok with contentment, not when there are still so many things to do. We all have delusions of grandeur when we are young...and it's not that...it's to really experience all the world has to offer and not just sit in one place forever.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Barry - You're old enough to be discontented - you don't have to be exactly 40. :)

    My question for myself and everyone else, then, is "So what are you going to DO about that discontentment?"

    I haven't decided yet, but I'm looking forward to the search.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 'Being you' means having Big Dreams, Erin. And going by the quality and depth of your posts, those dreams will have effects beyond anything you can see now. I look forward to them becoming reality:)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Cheering for you, Erin! Thanks for this post - so much of it resonated so deeply with me.

    Love you!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Erin,
    This post is brilliant. I want to say more, but I wouldn't even know where to start except to say that I totally relate to what you have expressed so well.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks Harry. I would like that to be true, but I'm not convinced.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you, Hap. Love you too!

    ReplyDelete
  17. It's very good to see you, Linda. How have you been?

    It's good to know others relate...because sometimes I still feel like I go through things along. It's so much more helpful to share it with others.

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you stick with it - as I know you will, 'cos your heart's set on it - you will be convinced. Oh, and there's no such thing as 'alone' on the Interwebs. What we think are the most personal struggles are in fact the most universal:)

    ReplyDelete
  19. Funny about the age thing, I started deconstructing when I was almost 40, and then continued for the next year or so. My wife said maybe it was my mid-life crisis, which in one way seems nonsense, but in another way seems to make some sense. It's a good point in one's life to re-evaluate things, and you're not a kid anymore, at least like I was when I jumped into the faith thing around 20 years old.

    So dammit, a mid-life crisis has the potential to be really *good*, and important, and necessary. And it seems perfectly normal for it to happen at age 40.

    I've been following along with your posts, thanks for writing and thinking out loud. I don't have a lot to say but am joying listening. And it's nice to know there are others in the same boat. :^)

    ReplyDelete
  20. I think there is something about middle age where I think "Damnit, if I'm not going to be true to myself now on the downhill run, then when?" And then there is also the learning to be comfortable in my own skin...learning not to care nearly as much what other people think...learning to be honest about some things at all cost.

    I already had my midlife crisis, 6 years ago. However, I think these recent posts highlight the culmination of it. I feel like maybe I can move forward for the first time in my life.

    ReplyDelete
  21. It's truly awesome to watch from here, Erin.

    ReplyDelete