Today, Heidi shared this:
But first, a disclaimer: my experiences are unique to me, and I don't mean to say that my process is anyone else's process, or my answers are anyone else's answers. I only hope to address how completely fucked up we all are, every last one of us, and how church-as-we-know-it often contributes to our fucked-up-ness. Church is a drug, like any, to some of us, and just as destructive. I'm not saying that is true for most, but I begin to wonder if those of us who tend towards addictive behaviors are more likely to be harmed in church environments. Addictive behavior isn't tolerated in church, so some of us swap drugs or alcohol or sex for church addiction. Those who are more skilled at moderation might have a much healthier go of church.
Sixteen days from today will mark the 4th anniversary of the day I almost died. It was about a month after I had left church and I was suicidal because of the condition my life was in because of who church had made me be. However, God took me down before I could take myself out. (Yes, that statement might contradict a previous post; get over it). This illness incapacitated me for almost a month, and by the time I was well enough to consider suicide again, I had realized that alcohol made it possible to cope with life. I rarely get hungover and other substances give me migraines. Easy choice.
I was drunk for much of the following six months. I would start some days as early as 9 AM Sometimes I would be intoxicated when I went to pick my sons up from school. Occasionally I had to sober up right before my husband came home from work. I had come to the revelation that God wasn't who I had always believed him to be, and if the church represented God, I wanted nothing to do with him or it ever again. A person lost in grief for a loved one, I looked for solace at the bottom of a bottle. So began the pendulum swing.
A song this afternoon drove me back into the hell that was those early months of my church-leaving. Pitch black, I had nothing left to lose and I sank into the miry despair that surfaces when one realizes ones entire existence is based on a lie, and lie onto lie. The first lie was what I had believed about who God was. The others were lies I had believed or told because of the first. Everything came crashing down after that, but like buildings we put up where they don't belong, in floodplains and on earthquake faults, when they fall to the ground, it is only then we can see the sun.
Today, it was almost as if I could feel myself in that February night, drunk nearly unconscious, about two months post-church. That was the night I sat by while one of my best friends committed adultery in the next room with a complete stranger we had picked up at at bar. Granted, I had been more sober earlier in the evening and had drug her out of the bar when I realized there was trouble brewing. However, she called him and told him where we were staying, and by the time he arrived, I was too intoxicated to care or to do anything about it. I even found myself cheering her on in my mind. Not cheering for sexual reasons, nor for marital reasons; every fiber of my being was about breaking the rules. Fuck God, fuck, church. Fuck it all. I was going to be free.
Earlier that day I had realized my crash was coming, my point of no return on ceasing to care, so with one last desperate kick to the surface, one more grasp towards hope, I had reached out to some other friends. However, these "friends" would rather see me drown if it meant they could get to their Purpose Driven Life group on time. (Forgiveness for that was given a long time ago, just to be clear, but God help me if I ever think a church event is more important than the well-being of a person I care about. Point made.) So I took a deep breath and went down. I have made my peace with it all, but for six months I lived in total shock at my behavior and what had happened, walking around like a zombie, mumbling, drunk.
For that entire season, my only, solitary prayer to a God I no longer believed in was something along the lines of this:
There will be more; I know this is dark, but it gets brighter.
Fallen: Part I
Amateur Therapy Hour
She's Like the Wind
Awakenings
Fallen II: Shit Makes Things Grow
The Saturnine Cycle
Light in the Windows
"I understand that when we have been indoctrinated so far to one side of an issue (ie. our behavior must be appropriate to be accepted in ‘church’) and we finally realize this is killing us, the knee-jerk response is to move as far from that position as we can. So we move to what we perceive is complete freedom. (Yes, I know this from my own life, as well as observing others). The pendulum has now gone from one extreme to the other. Now we no longer have to ‘behave,’ so we use our freedom to discover all the ways we can mis-behave. We attempt to see how close we can get to the cliff without falling off. I think in some ways this process can be helpful in loosing the grip of legalism, but it can be self-destructive when taken to extremes."I'm doing to dig into this because it's extraordinarily important, but I'm only able to touch on some of it in this first post. So you may have questions about the places I fail to elaborate; I will try to answer them in the comments or in future posts.
But first, a disclaimer: my experiences are unique to me, and I don't mean to say that my process is anyone else's process, or my answers are anyone else's answers. I only hope to address how completely fucked up we all are, every last one of us, and how church-as-we-know-it often contributes to our fucked-up-ness. Church is a drug, like any, to some of us, and just as destructive. I'm not saying that is true for most, but I begin to wonder if those of us who tend towards addictive behaviors are more likely to be harmed in church environments. Addictive behavior isn't tolerated in church, so some of us swap drugs or alcohol or sex for church addiction. Those who are more skilled at moderation might have a much healthier go of church.
* * *
Sixteen days from today will mark the 4th anniversary of the day I almost died. It was about a month after I had left church and I was suicidal because of the condition my life was in because of who church had made me be. However, God took me down before I could take myself out. (Yes, that statement might contradict a previous post; get over it). This illness incapacitated me for almost a month, and by the time I was well enough to consider suicide again, I had realized that alcohol made it possible to cope with life. I rarely get hungover and other substances give me migraines. Easy choice.
I was drunk for much of the following six months. I would start some days as early as 9 AM Sometimes I would be intoxicated when I went to pick my sons up from school. Occasionally I had to sober up right before my husband came home from work. I had come to the revelation that God wasn't who I had always believed him to be, and if the church represented God, I wanted nothing to do with him or it ever again. A person lost in grief for a loved one, I looked for solace at the bottom of a bottle. So began the pendulum swing.
A song this afternoon drove me back into the hell that was those early months of my church-leaving. Pitch black, I had nothing left to lose and I sank into the miry despair that surfaces when one realizes ones entire existence is based on a lie, and lie onto lie. The first lie was what I had believed about who God was. The others were lies I had believed or told because of the first. Everything came crashing down after that, but like buildings we put up where they don't belong, in floodplains and on earthquake faults, when they fall to the ground, it is only then we can see the sun.
Today, it was almost as if I could feel myself in that February night, drunk nearly unconscious, about two months post-church. That was the night I sat by while one of my best friends committed adultery in the next room with a complete stranger we had picked up at at bar. Granted, I had been more sober earlier in the evening and had drug her out of the bar when I realized there was trouble brewing. However, she called him and told him where we were staying, and by the time he arrived, I was too intoxicated to care or to do anything about it. I even found myself cheering her on in my mind. Not cheering for sexual reasons, nor for marital reasons; every fiber of my being was about breaking the rules. Fuck God, fuck, church. Fuck it all. I was going to be free.
Earlier that day I had realized my crash was coming, my point of no return on ceasing to care, so with one last desperate kick to the surface, one more grasp towards hope, I had reached out to some other friends. However, these "friends" would rather see me drown if it meant they could get to their Purpose Driven Life group on time. (Forgiveness for that was given a long time ago, just to be clear, but God help me if I ever think a church event is more important than the well-being of a person I care about. Point made.) So I took a deep breath and went down. I have made my peace with it all, but for six months I lived in total shock at my behavior and what had happened, walking around like a zombie, mumbling, drunk.
For that entire season, my only, solitary prayer to a God I no longer believed in was something along the lines of this:
Lord, protect me from myself,
because I don't give a damn anymore
and I know what I'm capable of.
because I don't give a damn anymore
and I know what I'm capable of.
There will be more; I know this is dark, but it gets brighter.
Fallen: Part I
Amateur Therapy Hour
She's Like the Wind
Awakenings
Fallen II: Shit Makes Things Grow
The Saturnine Cycle
Light in the Windows
47 comments:
Don't apologise about the darkness. It just is. Or was. Cheer instead about your courage 'cos you inspire me :)
Oh, the disconnect when everything comes down. Must break God's heart to see how much pain it puts us in :( But there just seems to be a time in every Christians life like this, when all the facades topple.
I know I've said it before, but it's true - it's so hard for you guys in the US. Religion-that-kills is ingrained into the very psyche of your country. That's what makes it all the more inspiring because so many people are seeing it for what it is and breaking free.
I love this post :)
Dark, yes, but it's reality. That's the most precious commodity we have, especially if we are going to have any kind of faith that works in the real world. If God is real, if our faith is real, then he and it must be real in the darkness as well as in the happier times.
I agree with Sue - in many ways it's easier for those of us who live in more secularised countries.
.
thanks e. is it okay if i don't yet forgive your "purpose driven friends"?
Wow, that's a powerful and raw prayer. I'm glad God saw fit to answer it. At least I'm guessing he answered it. ;)
Like Cindy, I simply don't get your friends who felt group meetings were more important than stopping to help a friend in need. But then, I've always been one to put people first. In fact, it's something that my IVCF staffworker back in college used to find frustrating to me. Several times, I'd be late to or even blow off a leadership and planning meeting because I decided that the conversation I was having with someone at the time was more important than making it to the meeting on time.
Wow!!
No other word correctly grasps my emotions toward this post Erin. You might as well have been writing about me.
Thank you for this, Erin. Your courage in talking about this helps me.
And I agree with Cindy...Grrr...
Erin,
This is so incredibly beautiful (your sheer honesty and transparency). As Sue said, please do not apologize for what you perceive as this writing/post being dark. I can see the hope and beauty in it, because I have a good feeling Papa brought you through. As well, I believe that whenever I see/hear/know someone is in a place of brokenness, Papa is doing something good within them, and they are about to embark on receiving Him and moving forward, out of the pit of despair.
I can relate to what you wrote about here. I, too, was in a very similar place in my past. So, I do understand how hitting "rock bottom" is sometimes where our stubborn Old Nature's have to die in order for us to embrace newness/change.
I see how this fits back with how many of us also are being de-constructed from the "addictive" relationships. After all, while we were in the institution, there were many reasons we "stayed" and followed on. We were "addicted" in many aspects to Religion and the "way" to live religiously. We bought in to so many ideas that "we could perform" well enough etc and "get" those warm-fuzzy feelings through being a "good Christian" in the definition that the System promoted.
Thus, I am perfectly aware than my de-construction of this "addictive" tendency is on-going.
Erin, I look forward to reading your follow-up post.
Blessings,
~Amy :)
http://amyiswalkinginthespirit.blogspot.com
As "dark" as this is, it makes me smile to think you are at a place where you can look back and see how far you've come...the changes in you are good ones & I love that I've been along for part of the ride!!
You inspire ME Sue! Thank you for talking with me about sharing hard stuff, it encouraged me to know I'm not the only one who struggles with it.
I know now in hindsight that every thing I went through that season was leading me closer to being a healthy person, so I can't say I regret one bit of it. People have wanted me to say I'm sorry and I regret it, but I'm not and I don't.
Barry - I know. Reality is much darker than churchianity would want to hear. There is so much pretending that our lives are all together, when really they are messy and ugly.
And yes, it probably is easier in some other countries.
Cindy - I would say yes, except even 6 months prior it could have been me, WAS me, putting church events ahead of everything, even my kids. I think much of church culture develops this behavior in people.
Jarred - I think that's much of why I am so reluctant to get back into church...I don't trust myself not to get my priorities all screwed up again, and I know what it did to people I love. I am a completely different person and I'm sure eventually I WILL trust myself again...but not yet.
Thanks Mike. I hope it was encouraging to you.
I'm glad it is helpful to you, Jim. I think I just want everyone to know that we're ALL really messed up, even me! LOL!
Amy - I love what you wrote, and glad to know I'm not the only one who sees the church as being addictive for some people. I know it was for me, and it really messed me up, because it seems at the time as such a harmless addiction.
Donna - Thank you. I'm glad you've been along for the ride too!
My husband is struggling with his relationship to the church and so I paid close attention to your story. Courageous of you to tell it.
"I begin to wonder if those of us who tend towards addictive behaviors are more likely to be harmed in church environments..."
Nah, I think the church is
"no respecter of persons" when it comes to hurting people. Your story is so moving - illustrates the capacity the church has to be destructive as well as your personal capacity to overcome.
Hmmm, yes there are dark elements to this story but I don't think of it as negative because I know the person you are today and this story is part of how you got where you are.
Thanks for sharing it. Its powerfully important.
I was visiting a few blogs who were doing, "The best posts for 2008" and came across this post about addictions which seem to me to fit this conversation. It makes the point we can get addicted to anything, even pain, and probably most of us are addicted to something.
Great post, my friend. I don't remember hearing this part of your story before. Thank you so much for the courage to share it. I look forward to reading more.
I like what Barbara said. I know a bit about where you are at now. So I take comfort in the knowledge that this story is headed in that direction.
Trace - I don't know. I would agree with you on some levels about the church not being a respecter of persons...but I think it might be the tendency for some of us to look for something that will meet all our needs and make us feel happy...and some people search for that answer in 'one' thing (different addictions) and others are better able to diversify for happiness.
Thanks Barbara. I love you for loving me.
Thanks Susan, I will check it out. I am not sure that most of us are addicted...but then maybe I'm wrong. Maybe the difference is those who focus on one thing vs. those who focus on many things...hmmm...
Gary - that's because I haven't told it before ;-)
Thanks for the vote of confidence. I would hope I'm a different person than I was then...but sometimes I wonder.
Thanks for sharing, Erin... Looking forward to hearing the rest.
How sad that people put "church meetings" above helping a drowning brother or sister. I know what you mean. It happens all the time.... I've learned a lot from being treated that way. It seems you have too.
I too became addicted to church and serving. You go through withdrawal when you leave and it's almost like you do need another drug. It can be hell just like drug detox...
You said "those who are more skilled at moderation might have a much healthier go of church." Yeah it seems that way but I think that we who aren't moderate have the advantage in the long run because we are more quick to see the sham, for we desperately need it not to be a sham! So we separate and disentangle sooner, even while inside the it. And many of the "moderate" folks are just the ones to be the coldest in my experience. They think they have it all together while they ignore the drowning-- How is that having it together?
You will be in my thoughts and prayers.... Can't wait to hear the rest... much love
A great contrast of a life of legalism vs the opposite extreme Erin. Escaping from the addictive grip of legalism is a tenuous one and not for the faint of heart. Coming to grips with the why of my own legalism was a difficult experience.. especially when I began to see the destructive effect it had on my kids.
Looking forward to your next installment Erin.
Wow, Erin. Thank you for sharing your story so candidly. It does make me so sad and angry that someone would place a 'meeting' before a person. However, it doesn't surprise me at all, having been in similar situations myself, and being pushed aside.
Church was a drug to me, as well. If I could just fit in, maybe I could be ok.
I'm looking forward to the rest of the story!
Manu - I agree that those of us who do "lose it" like this see things clearer have an advantage.
As to those who will watch someone drown, I have two theories about this: 1) they truly are so blind as to believe they have it all together, and cannot understand or 2) they know they do not have it all together but are afraid whatever that person has is contagious, in a sense.
But I think the teaching in some churches that says to sever all ties with a person who is questioning or falling or drowning or whatever is really to blame for it all.
Bob - The funny thing is I have always been a fighter against legalism, and was certain that what I was involved in WASN'T legalism because they said it wasn't legalism, it was "grace-based". But once out of all that I look back and see nothing but law. It's funny how some people disguise it.
Heidi - "If I could just fit in, maybe I could be ok. "
That really is the size of it, and maybe...well, you know they say low self esteem has much to do with addiction...I think maybe some people (me) suffer that same thing in church...instead of it being a substance, it is a behavior...but it still is simply a way we can feel good about ourselves and we will pour our hearts and souls into it to survive.
I can relate Erin.. I guess if you have to say that it is "grace based" then it probably isn't :)
Kinda along the lines of "doth protest too much"?
Oh Erin, there was soo much that I completely resonated with in this blog. I adore your transparency, and find that it is so refreshing to come across your blatant honesty. Can't wait to read the next installment. xo Stacy
Thanks Stacy...we can talk any time!
Hmm... thanks for sharing, Erin. I have been in that same situation, though at the time I wasn't quite in the same frame of mind. Actually, I am closer to that frame of mind now... I've realized there are two gods in my head, and I need to know which one is the real deal because that will determine what course I take next....
Hmm... thanks for sharing, Erin. I have been in that same situation, though at the time I wasn't quite in the same frame of mind. Actually, I am closer to that frame of mind now... I've realized there are two gods in my head, and I need to know which one is the real deal because that will determine what course I take next....
It makes perfect sense Katherine...to need to know which God you answer to. Just don't let people tell you that if you follow a kind gentle generous loving God that you are just inventing a God that is easy for you. Because I've heard that and it's wrong.
Clarification: I mean it's wrong to say you are inventing the God you want just because he's nice...not that it's wrong to view God that way....make sense?
I told someone once that I have to have God on my own terms. What I mean by that is that I have to feel the God I follow or else I just won't follow God at all...and this friend said that it's hard to have peace with taking God on our own terms...so I have to clarify...it's not taking God on my terms instead of his terms...it's taking God on my terms instead of everyone else's terms...like I don't have to follow the God that church tells me to follow. It has to be the God that resides in my spirit or he's no God to me.
Have you heard/seen Brian McLaren's song about being an Atheist? That's what I'm talking about.
I get it. Thanks. I have recognized for a while now that most religions (Christianity included) create god in their own image. I do not wish to do the same. Ha! So I am left in a state of spiritual limbo, so to speak.
I guess I need Him to show me... define Himself to me. And I am a little scared. The religious training of a lifetime screams against what I am doing - pentecostal pastors in the immediate family and all...
I can't follow a god who is abusive. Well, I suppose I could if I committed emotional suicide. Hmm... So I am waiting for Him to show me....
You're on the right track, Katherine. Let him tell you who he is for you, and try to tune out everyone else. Likely parts of how he reveals himself to you will be like how he reveals himself to others, but then parts of that will be uniquely yours, as well. I think God is big enough to come to each of us in the way we need to know him.
And I don't think that idea invalidates Jesus...I simply think that just as Jesus met people in many different ways depending on their need, so is God.
Isn't it funny how the people who claim God is a stupid little bastard never question whether they're making God in their own image :)
It's like, if God exists, then he has to be the kind that, if he was in human form, we would shun.
That is so weird :)
Cause Jesus would be like, homeless, and wear patchouli.
erin, my friend, I love you and am so very grateful our lives have intersected.
Would you think about writing how this journey has impacted your ideas and practices as a wife and mother and friend?
Darkness is a fact of spiritu pursuit. American Christians have no theology for suffering and unhappiness. Companionship in our places of despair makes the despair more bearable I think. The blog community you have created here and also your real life friends are along side you.
You are a loved woman no matter what!
Thanks Pam...it's weird to be in this place and I'm definitely grateful for the companionship.
I am sure I'll write about all aspects of this as time goes by...not sure how that will unfold as I have to just follow Spirit...or else it will be contrived. We'll see how it goes.
I think I said the exact same prayer once. But guess what. I don't THINK I'm fucked up anymore. But others will have to be the judge of that.
But that means there is hope. (as if anyone would think I'M a role model)
LOL Nate...I don't think I'm fucked up anymore, either...but then there is the coming to terms with that, the unraveling of years of thinking I was fucked up and of other people thinking that...it's a weird mind-bender. But it's a fun spin in the blender of life, for sure!
Post a Comment