1.20.2008

Chili All Over the Kitchen

Tonight, Pam and I had the great fun of spending a couple hours with Kathy Escobar, co-Pastor of The Refuge in Bloomfield, Colorado. She has been in Portland this weekend with her husband José, visiting with the folks at The Bridge. She spoke at church this morning, and I do want to talk about some of what she said there...in another post. Right now I want to talk about our "girl time" this evening.

If you know any of the three of us, you can guess what subject we spent most of our evening on: Women (and girls) in the Church. Their roles in church leadership, marriage, and their relationships with each other. We even spoke for awhile about the issues facing young women who are growing up in the church today.

As the last year or so has gone on, I have found myself increasingly aware of something I am passionate about. I desperately want to see women set free from evangelical bondage...that of their roles as women, wives, daughters and mothers; for some of you, those statements reek of feminism. I won't apologize for it, but I will qualify it. I don't want women to become men, I want women to become themselves.

I have spent most of my adult life in the biblical womanhood role, and this is a dangerous thing, one which I liken to a pressure-cooker. While I have heard there being some disagreement as to whether or not an actual pressure-cooker will ever literally explode, this imagery in reference to a situation is widely accepted as meaning such, and so I choose to use it.

When a woman is subjected to years of traditional teachings about submission and subservience, when she is taught how to dress, how to behave, how to talk, how to think...which like it or not is what is happening in much of modern Christianity, even in progressive Christianity...eventually she will explode; meaning any turn of events which will release the pressure, and often it will be ugly.

Because the food my husband and I had been fed about biblical roles for husband and wife are so twisted and wrong, neither of us could ever completely swallow it. I tried, mind you. I read all the books, I did the good wife thing, I served every way I knew how. I choked it down, making every effort not to retch in the process. But in the end, not only did this pressure destroy my personality, my husband hated that I had gone from colorful to shades of gray.

When we met, I was windy and wild; all vivid, Technicolor me. That is the woman he fell in love with, he told me so. But over the years, decades, evangelicalism washed all the color right out of me...load after load of cheap detergent and hot water. Burning and washing, taking great care to strip from me every last bit of who I was as an individual, and raising up a monochrome stepford wife. Some of you might call this process transformation, I call it oppression, for nothing in my heart of hearts was ever transformed, it was simply controlled, pressurized.

You might feel I am speaking too strongly about my experiences; I assure you I am not. Words cannot convey the ways in which I compressed my true self, smaller and smaller, until it became the black hole of who I used to be. For years I strove to be that Better Christian Woman; it damn near killed me, that is not an exaggeration. Three years ago now, I struggled intensely not to kill myself, it was only facing the reality of my kids growing up without me that prevented it. I no longer had the strength to be Better Christian Woman, and I collapsed. There came a place of meltdown, a critical mass when my evangelical cooker failed and suddenly there was chili all over the kitchen. There is no Quicker-Picker-Upper in the world that could have handled it.

All those years of pent-up, pressurized, Technicolor Erin exploded all over the place. She was dying to get out. Yes, it was messy for awhile, but something strange happened. Jesus came along with His transcendental paper towels and began cleaning it up. It's taken three years to come this far, not to say I am healed, past-tense, but healing, Present Perfect Progressive. He's still cleaning, but I'm complete in Him, as I am, in who I am in this very moment. I don't need to be pressure-cooked, I'm already done.

Never again will there be chili all over my kitchen.

Pt 1: Chili all Over the Kitchen
Pt 2: Harlots, Heretics and Hussies
Pt 3: Liars and the Men who Love Them
pt 4: A Narrow Path, a Crooked Line, Fly

51 comments:

Sue said...

Ahhh, babe, you rock :)

Pistol Pete said...

Yes, pressure cookers can explode. Ours exploding when I was very young and my mom got a very bad burn.

Each of us definitely has a unique God-given identity. When my wife and I first married, I assumed she would be a working professional (given her level of education and experience). She tried it for awhile and it didn't work.

So, she became what is often called a "stay-at-home mom". For her, the role has been very rewarding and she has certainly excelled at it. She's helped raise over a dozen foster children along with our two birth and two adopted, special-needs children.

For my wife, the "traditional role" for women has worked beautifully. Sadly, some folks look down on her as if she must be a sort of "Stepford Wife" because she chooses to stay home.

Women (and men) need to experience the freedom to choose the role God has carved out for them - no matter what tradition or modernity dictate.

grace said...

Erin,
I'm glad that you are free to be colorful, windy, and wild again!

One Voice of Many said...

Erin,
I also have gone through similar indoctrination. I realized one day that I used to have an opinion about things. The church model had caused me to grow focused on not behaving unGodly-womany that I sold myself short on my things.

In our process of taking things apart it was difficult to know what to question and what not to -- evolution, homosexuality -- all of those topics that are hotly debated by misquoted scripture. When I finally realized that God wasn't going to strike me dead (immediately, at least..haha) for my questions, I gave myself permission to take that "submissive" teaching and throw it right in the can.

Now I'm not a control freak nor do I have issues with trying to manipulate my husband so, to him, it wasn't a big deal anyway. But it was nice to take away that issue that rolled around in my head.

I rambled.... sorry. :-)

Michelle

donnav said...

I love the "technocolor" you!!
This accepting who we are and finding the depths of who we can be is exciting. I'm happy & thank God to be on this path with you!!

Erin said...

Thanks Sue!

Erin said...

Pete - My story is from personal experience, and I desire to speak freedom to the women who are being taught that being a "Godly" woman only looks one way...one type of role, one manner of dress, one way of thinking.

My point is that many women feel overwhelmingly pressured (by their churches) into being a certain person and filling a certain role; not that it's wrong for women to fill a traditional role if that is what they want. I've always been a stay home mom, because that is what we have chosen for our family.

I also have know stay-home mom's who are miserable and would work outside the home if she and her husband weren't being told that it was undesirable to God.

Erin said...

Grace - Thanks! You know you have been instrumental in my walk towards freedom.

Erin said...

Michelle - That's exactly what I'm talking about. Submission is a teaching that has been manipulated into something it's not and it's good for us to question it as it stands.

Cindy said...

so, so well said, erin.

Erin said...

Thanks Cindy! :-)

Erin said...

Donna - Thanks!

Barbara said...

Check it out: I am sitting here with headphones on listening to what Kathy said at your church yesterday (Donna sent it to me). I am going to write about it too...She's awesome. I totally have a flogging machine.

As for you, Erin, i see the Technicolor you and am so sorry (but understand) what you mean by this:

"I compressed my true self, smaller and smaller, until it became the black hole of who I used to be."

Its unbelievable how often the opposite of what Christ wants to happen in us through "church" turns destructive.

Barbara said...

PS I want some of that chili and can't get Portland out of my mind. Is that where God wants me? I hope so.

Erin said...

Barbara - I plan to write about the flogging machine, too.

It's too bad so much of what we are taught and what the Bible actually says get twisted into this mess of half-truths.

I can't say where God wants you to live, but I definitely know God wants you to come for a visit!

Julie said...

Thank you so much for sharing. The freedom from this oppression is a mighty goal.

I just had to listen recently to my mom go off about a group of women at her church who after years of being married using their maiden names finally decided to submit to a "godly marriage" and take their husbands names. I nearly got sick at the idea of years of these women's personalities and identities being worn away. I went off on her on the stupidity of insisting that cultural practices like names have anything to do with biblical ideas for marriage, but I can't crack her ideas of what submission means (the language and ideas I grew up with).

Erin said...

Julie - It all has to do with removing people's choice, either directly or subversively. In an out-loud voice we are told we have freedom to be whoever we want, but the whispers and glances speak otherwise, forcing us to submit or be judged.

Gary Means said...

A friend of mine is an interim pastor in a church where certain members of the congregation hold to very traditional views of women. Though it is a minority, there is another segment which doesn't want those people to leave, so they side with them when the issue is discussed.

As an interim, my friend is not in a position to try to transform this situation. He was surprised to find people still wrestling with this issue, which he felt was dealt with decades ago. His denomination has ordained women for a long time now.

Being part of the oppressor gender, I cannot fully "know" what you face. However, I can empathize, based on my own experience of being pressured to conform to the artificial standards of the evangelical subculture. That's part of why I feel spiritually adrift. I have no church home, because I don't see a church with people like me -- whatever that means.

I feel like I need to change if I ever want to be part of a congregation again, at least one that my family would be willing to be part of. But I don't think I can change. To do so would be to deny who I am. Hmmmm, this is sounding familiar, eh?

Erin said...

Sounds very familiar, Gary. And I don't mean to suggest that women are the only ones who are oppressed, that's just what I have taken issue with.

There are many kinds of oppression in the church: spiritual, financial, cultural (i.e. what kinds of music/movies we enjoy) and I do believe men are oppressed as well, by the whole "spiritual leader of the home" myth.

Ché Vachon said...

Erin, I love how you explained this. The pressure cooker analogy sure fits with what I've experienced...
Love you lots.

Erin said...

Ché - Thanks. I think a lot of women have experienced it, and my idealistic self wants it to stop.

Love you too!

Lyn said...

So well said Erin. You are a beautiful free spirit, don't let anyone put you back in that pressure cooker. Love you and who you are.

Gary Means said...

Erin, no, I didn't take your comments to be exclusivistic. I wholeheartedly support your position and your desire to see this change. I think Rachelle Mee Chapman's comments on this subject as it pertains to the emerging church are quite sad. Not that much difference in how the EMC treats women as leaders than is the case with most of evangelicalism. Big words, little deeds.

Erin said...

Thanks Lyn! You're awesome.

Erin said...

Gary - I wasn't worried that you thought I was being exclusive, I just wanted to validate your thoughts that it's not an issue exclusive to women and their roles.

And in the words of the legendary band Warrant:

"Big talk is just talk, unless you're backing it up".

But that's another post entirely.

Sue said...

Oh, now that's just plain playing nasty.

Erin said...

Sue - What, quoting Warrant is nasty now? Hehe.

Sue said...

You know exactly the effect that will have on my internal radio station (Radio Susie).

Problem is, with Warrant it's always double-shot Tuesday. I get Big Talk *and* a neat segue into Sometimes She Cries.

So thanks. Thanks a goddamn bunch.

Erin said...

I'm sorry Sue...wait, no I'm not. Heaven isn't too far away, you know?

And it's not Tuesday.

Sue said...

No, it's not too far away. I'm just not sure how to get there. But apparently, even though I ain't got money nor any gas, I can' get where I'm going if I swing real fast.

Doesn't sound like a particularly Christian worldview, but there you go.

See, these Christian women - you liberate them, take them out of their pressure cooker kitchens, and they become nasty, feisty little creatures, spewing out their musical evil. Shame, Erin, shame.

Erin said...

(Erin's just laughing and laughing...)

If you think about baseball you can swing all night...

Shame is right...

Sue said...

Hehe. Me laughing here too. But that's enough Warrant on an empty stomach. I don't want to begin my TUESDAY hurling.

It is so Tuesday. You damn Americans. You think that just cos it's Monday over there that it's Monday everywhere else.

;)

Erin said...

Hey, we're not the ones who put snowmen on our Christmas cards even though it's SUMMER!

Sue said...

No, that's very true (and a bit lame, but we'll let that pass).

I don't buy those cards anyway, so you're not talking to me (you're talking to the hand, but you can't see me so I just thought I'd let you know)

:)

Thanks for sharing some passive aggression with me! It's been really fun!! Now, I really need to go and eat or else I'm going to pass out.

kathyescobar said...

hey erin, it was so fun hanging out with you both and i LOVED this post! you articulated it so well...i will be sharing with my ex-good-christian-women group for sure...stay in touch. i am so glad to share the journey with people like you...may your colors become more vivid, deep, rich, mixed together in all kinds of crazy beautiful ways in the months and years to come...kathy

Erin said...

Hi Kathy - You'll have to ignore the previous series of comments, Sue and I have a mutually good-natured but harassing relationship. ;-)

I so very much loved talking with you last night. I can't even explain how encouraging it is to me the progress you are making on this subject.

More power to the ex-good-Christian women everywhere!

Barry said...

I'm so glad I'm married to a woman who's happy being herself and doesn't try to conform to the Stepford Church Wives sort of image. If she did, she wouldn't be the wonderful person she is today.

As you said, Erin, it's not only women who are forced into a mould that doesn't fit. For years I was forced into the mould of 'good Christian man'. In the end I couldn't fit - mild mannered, meek, inoffensive and non-opinionated (i.e. church doormat) just isn't my style. Nor is listening exclusively to worship music, wearing a suit and tie to church or cutting myself off from the real world.

We should encourage people to be who they really are in God, not try to force them into conformity - whichever sex they happen to belong to.

Sue said...

Amen, Barry

Erin said...

Barry - I wish I had been able to avoid the conformity...I would have been a lot happier.

I'm so thankful, though, that I have found people who agree with me about this craziness

Cindi said...

As I'm getting more settled in, I'm more able to get online and check in on your blog. You have such a beautiful and talented way of writing in a way ppl can relate and understand.

I never knew all those years you were so miserable, but I'm very happy for you that you're finding your way out of the fog and being who you truly are - a bright, shining - and yes, a technicolor woman. You inspire me :)

Erin said...

Oh, thank you Cindi. I'm so glad to hear you are feeling more settled there in the land of the midnight sun! Hehe.

I was very good at hiding my misery because I didn't think I had a choice. I know you could have told me differently if I had let on, but that's just who I was at the time. I was an unwavering evangelical.

Love you!

Mary said...

Thanks for sharing about this. It's amazing what people will do when they think it will please God.

Erin said...

Mary - I agree. I wish it weren't so.

Pam Hogeweide said...

ex-good-Christian women

oh, that's good. that needs to either be the title of your book or at the very least the topic for one of those synchro blogs you are fond of doing. that would be sooooooooo much fun to write, don't ya think? i know this post had a lot of good stuff in it, but I know that you have a helluva lot more to say on the subject of Ex-good christian women.

Last night was great. Loved the meeting of our hearts and minds with Kathy. Glad that worked out...
and I'm glad that you are out of that weird place of religious bondage that held you back. I love that you are free and getting freer! You inspire me!!!

Erin said...

Pam - "Ex-good-Christian-women" is Kathy's thing...I just borrowed it.

Thanks for being my friend. I'm so glad we have each other to share some of these controversial views with!

Nate said...

Erin I have the same passion. Not just for women, but everyone in religion. Men have the same expectations pushed on them as well. The participation in the different "Men's Groups" and things like that.

One of the groups was about setting your heart free as a man and not being afraid to do manly things. I went to 1 meeting, then never went back. I was already me, and did not need to be taught how to be me.

I guess a lot of the bondage I broke was not worrying about what people thought. But what God thought of me. I had no convictions of improper behavior on me, so why worry about it. It was not always that way, but it is now. I would like to help others find that.

Erin said...

Nate - I hear ya. I wish it was easier to pass on to others.

Hanan Merrill said...

As a man, I could never completley resonate with your feelings as I haven't been there myself. However, listening to your experience, I'm impressed with how what you're experiencing more and more is what Jesus came to free each one of His kids (girls, boys, women, men) to be able to do. To be the beautiful individual person that He's created us as and to heal our brokenness to allow that individual beauty to shine brighter.

Of course we all know that life has valuable trials, but may you never feel the devil trying to stuff you back in the pressure cooker of other's expectations again!!!

Good post!

Calia77 said...

Hi, thanks for writing this. It sums up so much of what I feel about being a Christian woman. We're not taught how to be who we are. And hence we either try to squeeze ourselves into a place where we don't belong (and turn ourselves grey, as you put it), or act out and become a caricature of ourselves.

And it doesn't help when (I'm not saying all here) Christian guys don't know who they are, so are frightened of the technicolour and push us towards the grey. As a single Christian woman in her 30's, I'm tired of scared little Christian men thinking I should be more grey and then they MIGHT be interested in me.

By the way, found you through the lovely, and also very technicolour, Barbara.

Erin said...

Thanks Hanan. That's really what it's about - individual beauty.

Erin said...

Thanks for commenting, Calia. I know there are some women who flourish inside these standards and I don't take issue with that, but so many of us die a little every time we are told how to be a better wife/mother/daughter/hostess/priestess etc.

I'm no expert on dating, but I would say don't go gray to find a husband, because you will be setting yourself up for him having a certain expectation of who you are.

Post a Comment