3.31.2006
Leaving
I hesitate to write about this, but the other day I was faced with a dilemma. There are people in my life whom I have not admitted to yet that I do not intend to return to the church I am out-of. I can't say for sure that I ever intend to return to church at all. I know I have said all this before. Call me bitter, call me fallen, call me a giver-upper. I have heard so many opinions and arguments and idealistic views about staying in the church in order to change it rather than just leaving.
But I guess at some point I have to be honest with people. This is what I came up with. I don't think any of the people in my life that this is directed at read my blog, but I needed to say it notheless.
I am a leaver, guilty as charged. I will not apoogize. Let me rephrase that. I have decided to stop apologizing. My reasons are both similar to many other "leavers", and also different and quite personal. I have fought mightily against the spirit of "leaving", and I have lost. I never for a moment asked for this, never looked for this. I was heartbroken over my leaving, for the loss of relationships and fellowship and corporate faith. It has taken me almost a year stop fighting and to accept that God has put me here on purpose and to believe that I am not just responding (to my hurts on the church) from the pit of my humanity.
I am not into being a "church basher" nor do I have ANY issues with those who remain in churches. I believe we are all in different places and we are all called differently. If a person feels they are to be in the church, I believe that is where God wants them to be for His purposes. But I don't believe that being "in church" is the only place God wants us, relationally speaking.
Some may say that the time it has taken me to come to terms with this season of my faith is really evidence of the Holy Spirit's tugging at my heart for being "fallen away". I can say in complete honesty that my Spirit feels no peace at the notion of returning, and complete peace in the place where I am. Maybe I am wrong in my assessment of this, maybe my discernment is off. If that is true, then the Lord may call me on it. But needless to say I have prayed and wept and sought after the Lord on this, and always come to the same conclusion. How long will He have me out? He has given me no definitive answer. I trust that as long as I keep my eyes and my Spirit open, He will show me when (if) it is time to return.
I have struggled with the possiblity that I cannot be a Christ-follower if I abandon His Bride, the church. However, that notion of abandonment depends how you define "church". I define the church two ways: Big C "Church", and little c "church". Church (Big C) being the Body of Christ in it's entirety, consisting of all believers worldwide who are working to further the Kingdom, to love one another, and serve those in need. The church (little c) is the building, consisting of a group of members meeting together on a regular basis. The church is a part of the Church. I believe it's possible to belong to one and not the other. I believe He creates some people to witness to creation from a place of separation from the world, some from a place of integration with the world.
There is good and bad aspects to both types of people. But people IN the "church" tend to see themselves as all good and the "leavers" as all bad. I see it this way: some people who belong to a church do not see themselves as needing to also belong to the worldwide or even communitywide Church mission to serve those around us and love unconditionally. Likewise, some people who leave the "church" are free-radicals that see themselves as completely autonomous and function quite unhealthily.
I don't believe that I have broken off from the Body. I believe as long as I am serving Him in my specific role, I am serving as the member I am called to be, if that be an arm or a leg or an eye. However, I am still part of the Body…at least I consider myself to be, even if my brothers and sisters don't. If they would like to say I am not serving Christ, I would like to counter that with the fact that God has challenged me to serve those who don't yet belong to His family (which I believe is our primary role in the world - to evidence Jesus in service and then point to Him when we are asked why we serve) in greater and more tangible ways since I have been out of the church than I was ever led to do from within the church.
In this time in my life, my Christian "community" consists of good friends and families, coffee shops and living rooms. I meet regularly with other believers, we speak of Christ and God and Scripture. We hold each other accountable. We speak of our responsibility to serve the world, to be Jesus to people who might never otherwise meet Him.
I understand the (growing) concern over the "leavers". It is an epidemic, it seems, and I will admit that some churches are losing their visionaries and pioneers. This saddens me in general, I see this as a great loss. If we have no one to tell us where we are going, how will we know when we arrive? If the pioneers and the planters cannot learn to live together in harmony, then we have a huge problem. Am I part of the problem? Yes. I pioneered myself clean out of the church. Are the planters part of the problem? Of course. They build structures where they ought to pitch tents. That is another post altogether.
What I would say to leaders who are concerned about the "leavers" is this: If you don't want them to leave, you must make them feel heard. Simple as that. This in no way means you must concede to all their suggestions or bend to their concerns. But you must hear what they say and take it into account, lay it before the Lord in humility and ask Him what to do with what these people have said. And they must know that you are willing to seek the Lord on anything that you hear more than a few voices saying. You must be willing to admit that some changes need to be made, and it's these voices you need in order to determine what those changes are. If you admonish the voices of disillusionment and dissent, they WILL LEAVE. They will not feel understood and will seek to find their value as Christ-followers elsewhere. You will lose them. If you do not take steps to hear them, you do not retain the right to criticize them for leaving.
My bottom line: the isssue of "leaving" must not be generalized, it must be viewed as intensely personal, an issue of Spirit and conscience best dealt with between the Believer and their Savior, and possibly including the people closest to the believer who are invited to hold them accountable.
Please do not pass judgment on me until you have walked a mile in my Birkenstocks, or Vans, as it may be.
Thanks for listening.




