Judgment: condemnation of wrong, the decision (whether severe or mild) which one passes on the faults of others. (From Vine's for Greek Strong's 2917
krima).
Judgmental: Inclined to make judgments, especially moral or personal ones. (From
The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language)I tend to be harshly critical of people in the church who quickly and unfairly judge other people's (perceived) wrongs. I am also critical of a variety of (perceived) faults in the church.
Hm. Been thinking about this a lot lately. Am I equally guilty of judging if I am commenting on other people's judgmentalism? If I say "they are so judgmental", does that put me in a place of judgmentalism? Is the saying that something is wrong in the church...if that thing is not seen as wrong to the people in the church...even if other people around me agree it is wrong....a form of judgment? You follow?
Then again, is expressing my opinion about things I see in the church that hurt people and are detrimental to their spirituality a bad thing? Do we have to realize that people have the right to speak out against problems in the church?
This is such a challenging subject for me. Someone recently called me on it. I received a flyer in the mail from the church I am out-of about an upcoming campaign or program of some sort. My immediate response (this was only in the company of one very good friend) was...drumroll...
"Gag me." Rolls eyes.
This friend said, "Why are you so judgmental? This program will probably be a good thing for many people, drawing them nearer to Christ and to other believers." [Paraphrase]
She's right.
But I wonder...it's certainly not that I believe these sorts of "programs" do NO good at all...I just am asking the question "are there better ways?" Do we in the church sell ourselves short by adhering religiously to programs and campaigns and systems and such?
Yes, it's true that whatever approach the church has will do
some good for
some people. But what if we were to do things differently....would other approaches to "church" do
more good for
more people? I'm not just talking conversion rates...in fact that's one of my lowest priorities.
I'm talking making people's lives and relationships better.
Are we capable of doing church in such a way that people's lives are affected, not just on Sunday morning, but for the rest of their lives? Not just by a well delivered sermon but by example of the leadership? Not just by making church a "safe" environment, but by making church an incarnational environment?
Do these questions make me guilty of judgment? Maybe not...not at this moment in this blog post. I think judgment becomes a problem when I am angry about these things...not with a righteous anger but with a hurt and spiteful anger. When I am on my soapbox, lecturing others about the evils of the IC. When I am crying because the current model has hurt me so deeply. When I am sulking because I realize that I just didn't fit in and "it's not fair"!
But right now at this moment I have my cracked-pot human version of "righteous anger". I am angry because people (as a generalization in leadership) will not step outside their boxes...will not move beyond what they know for a fact "works"...and be willing to admit that
"Anything that is not moving forward in God is actually moving back, because you don’t stand still in God. We could call it nominal Christianity. Backslidden is maybe a better, more honest, and, hopefully, more shocking term." - Graham Cooke
And as a sidenote, I better qualify that with his definition of "backslidden":
"To be a backslidden Christian doesn’t mean that you’re not attending church, but that your experience of God has not appreciably grown in the last twelve months. You are still struggling in prayer the same way you were five years ago. Your ability to express the character of Jesus is just as poor now as it was a couple of years ago. You’re still just as prone to blow up and be upset and offended."
And yet I can't stop thinking about something else Graham Cook has said:
"It’s so easy to quit and walk away and make religious excuses. You don’t learn to be trusted by God when everything goes well, but when everything is against you, and you still stand. No one wants to listen to you, but God hasn’t told you to leave, so you’ve still got to be committed there, without a bad attitude. You have to have a good one. You’re there for a reason."...
..."You have to know the favor of God that’s on your life—favor that works when everything is against you. God doesn’t just want to be around when things are going well. He loves to be around when things are going badly, because it’s in those places that He does something quite extraordinary in our lives."
And while I realize that I have effectively quit and walked away and made religious excuses, does this mean I have to go back? Was I there for a reason? Do I have to have a good attitude? It's all those things that chased me out. I could no longer have a good attitude and no longer saw my reason for being there. But is the fact that I have been pondering judgment an indicator of something? Is the concept that I am equally guilty of judging a lesson I need to learn?
One other Graham Cooke quote and then I'm done. I think this is a fantastic outline for what many "emerging" type churches are aiming for...
"I believe the Lord is looking for places where He can come and stand. He’s not looking for places to visit. He’s looking for places to come and live. I think the Lord is heartily sick of visitations. He’s looking for habitations....
"He’s looking for certain characteristics. He’s looking for love, friendship, companies of people who are best friends, who are committed to Him, and to one another, because God doesn’t come to meetings . He comes to companies of friends....
[Lily's Note: For you U.S. people, the use of the word "meetings" here means "church services".]"Why? Because it’s the thing that He loves most of all. It’s friendship, relationship. Where there are a bunch of people who are living out the first two commandments—love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, mind and strength, and love your neighbor—that’s whoever you happen to be standing next to at any given point in time—love that person as you love yourself. "
How does this all tie together? What I see in myself is wanting the church to expereinece "companies of friends" more than "meetings". While my heart for this is well-intentioned, it's easy for me to become judgmental of the church and it's propensity for "programs" in the same ways that I feel judged for having left church because I felt I could no longer stay there and participate in structured "programs" and remain healthy. I see the "structured programs" of church as a deterrent to our collective "moving forward in God".
And while I don't see myself as backslidden by Graham Cooke's definition....my image of God has grown tremendously in this season of "hiddenness"...I stand convicted of my whiny attitude and religious excuses for having left and I admit that while I'm still uncertain of whether or not I ought to return to the place I am out-of, I know there is a place for me, a reason I am there, in the Church (Big C).
What is that place? That is the question of the day. Don't know, still seeking it.